Authors: Michael C. Bustamante, Duane S. Cronin, University of Waterloo
Abstract
Finite element (FE) head models (HMs) are used to calculate brain tissue deformation from impact or acceleration events and the outcomes are often summarized using single-value metrics to represent whole-brain response, such as 95th percentile maximum principal strain (MPS95). Contemporary FE HMs use multiblock hexahedral meshes, necessary for accurate numerical results; however, different head models predict different brain responses for the same loading condition and comparison between models are obfuscated by single-value metrics (e.g., MPS95). At present, there exists no method for direct three-dimensional spatial comparison of predicted brain response between different HMs under the same spatial domain, owing to differing brain mesh geometry, detail, and topology.
In the present study a novel approach for spatial alignment of contemporary HM brain meshes and strains was developed by mapping them to a common target geometry using voxelization with a novel interpolation method, enabling the comparison of results between different FE models. First, three contemporary HMs: GHBMC-M50, GHBMC-F05, and THUMS-AM50, were subjected to an impact simulation (3.5 m/s rear head impact). Then their brain mesh and strains were each interpolated to a refined voxel representation via interpolation, and the voxel representations were each mapped (aligned) to a common target geometry. A voxel-wise difference between two spatially aligned strain distributions was then calculated for each HM pair. Severe divergence in high-strain distribution was found between the GHBMC-M50 and THUMS-AM50 having a low overlap (dice similarity coefficient = 0.111), despite both representing the 50th percentile male under an identical impact.

Type: Full Paper, Research
Keywords: Finite Element Head Model, Nonlinear Registration, Overlay Metrics, MNI structural atlas, Brain Model, Impact, Strain distribution
© Stapp Association, 2026
Access Additional Papers from the 70th Stapp Car Crash Conference
View additional full papers from the 70th Stapp Car Crash Conference.
- A Dynamic Safety System for Mitigating the Severity of Motor Vehicle AccidentsAuthors: William G. Broadhead, Theodore Zinke, Automotive Safety Research, Inc.; Jacqueline G. Paver, Center for Injury Research Abstract The advent…
- Age-Associated Pediatric Head and Neck Injury Patterns in Motor Vehicle Crashes: A Multi-Source Descriptive AnalysisAuthors: Karthik Somasundaram, Klaus Driesslein, Dale Halloway, Medical College of Wisconsin; Valentina Graci, Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia/Drexel University Abstract Objective:…
- Biofidelity Evaluation of THOR-AV 50th Percentile Male Dummy in 50 km/h Frontal Impact ConditionsAuthors: Z. Jerry Wang, Humanetics Innovation Solutions; Matthew P. Reed, University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute Abstract This paper provides…
- Biomechanical Responses and Injuries of Male Post Mortem Human Subject Seated in Production Seats in Moderate-to-High-Speed Rear ImpactsAuthors: Yun-Seok Kang, Reed Finfrock, Timothy Wensink, Randee Hunter, Amanda M. Agnew, Injury Biomechanics Research Center, The Ohio State University;…
- Characterization of Rider and Powered Two-Wheeler Kinematics in Full-Scale PMHS Crash TestingAuthors: Daniel A. Meringolo, Yun-Seok Kang, Injury Biomechanics Research Center, The Ohio State University; Jolyon Carroll, Shiyang Meng, Autoliv Research…
- Evaluation of 50th Percentile Male ATD Biofidelity in Moderate-Speed Rear Impact Sled Tests Compared to PMHSAuthors: Angela Tesny, William Millis, Colton Thomas, Kevin Moorhouse, Jason Stammen, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, Vehicle Research and Test…
- Factors and Mechanisms Related to Skeletal Ankle Injury during Frontal Motor Vehicle CollisionsAuthors: Devon L. Albert, University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute; Elizabeth M. McNeil, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration; Warren N….
- Historical Review of the Use of the Hybrid III ATDs in Rear Impact Testing and ValidationAuthors: Priya Prasad, Prasad Engineering, LLC; David C. Viano, Pro-Biomechanics, LLC; Chantal S. Parenteau, Roger Burnett , Design Research Engineering;…
- Identifying Representative Front Crash Test Conditions from EDR Pulses and Body-Region Injury PatternsAuthors: Matthew L. Brumbelow, Insurance Institute for Highway Safety Abstract As front crashworthiness has improved in relatively low-exposure, high-severity configurations,…
- Influence of Joint Structure in Multibody Model on Behavior Analysis of Crash Test DummyAuthors: Masatoshi Usui, Yasuhiro Matsui, Naruyuki Hosokawa, Yoshinori Tanaka, National Traffic Safety and Environment Laboratory, Tokyo, Japan Abstract This study…
- Parametric Investigation of the Effect of Brain Cortical Surface Representation on Strain Prediction: From a Smooth Cortex to Shallow Sulci in Multi-Block-Based All-Hexahedral Head ModelsAuthors: Sakib Ul Islam, Kewei Bian, Haojie Mao, Western University Abstract Developing finite element (FE) brain models with detailed sulci…
- Quantitative Assessment of Neck Injury Criteria Against Tissue-Level Response Using a Detailed Computational Neck Model in Frontal, Lateral, Rear, and Oblique ImpactsAuthors: Matheus A. Correia, Duane S. Cronin, University of Waterloo Abstract Neck injury criteria are increasingly used with computational Human…
- Relevant Vehicle Front-End Components for Pedestrian Laboratory Testing to Address Real-World Pedestrian Injuries When Struck by Passenger Vehicles With High Hood HeightsAuthors: Becky Mueller, Jessica Jermakian, Insurance Institute for Highway Safety Abstract In the United States, pedestrian deaths account for 18%…
- Response of the Male and Female PMHS Foot and Ankle to Axial LoadingAuthors: Warren N. Hardy, The Ohio State University; Elizabeth M. McNeil, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration; Devon L. Albert, University…
- Rotations of Rearward-Facing Child Restraint Systems and Excursions of the Paediatric Head During Frontal and Frontal-Oblique Impact Sled TestsAuthors: Declan A. Patton, Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia Abstract Objective: For a paediatric anthropomorphic test device (ATD) seated in rearward-facing…
- The Use of a Pre-Pretensioner Belt to Reduce Forward Leaning in Vehicle Occupants in Anticipation of a Pre-Crash ManeuverAuthors: Maitland Witmer, Valentina Graci, Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia/Drexel University; Madeline Griffith, Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia Abstract The objective of…
- Time-history Analysis of Model Validation and Corridor ComparisonAuthors: Guy Nusholtz Abstract To evaluate how data quality can influence the analysis of biomechanical impact tests, computationally generated sets…
- Video-based Accurate Kinematics Estimation from High-Speed Human MotionAuthors: Qiantailang Yuan, Svein Kleiven, Xiaogai Li, KTH Royal Institute of Technology Abstract Human posture and kinematics estimation from video…
- Voxel-Interpolation and Mapping Applied to Multiblock Hexahedral Finite Element Head Models Enables Response Metric Spatial ComparisonAuthors: Michael C. Bustamante, Duane S. Cronin, University of Waterloo Abstract Finite element (FE) head models (HMs) are used to…